I say that but actually the one exp I played (wotlk) was actually skilled. Or at least I played a comp in which, if you made just 1 mistake you lost instantly because of it. It was really fun, most of the time. Other comps had it really easy and some no-lifer PVE heroes had it extra easy and got their rating from stuff rather from skill.
Heard that tbc before the azirroth glaives was really good multiple times, so you're probably right