Well I can't argue with your logic. I still personally think s1mple deserves #1, but to each their own. I'll admit part of me wants s1mple to be MVP simply because of how hard he worked to get where he is. I'll say dev1ce is probably the better teammate but I'd wager someone else on Astralis would get the 'best teammate' achievement XD. Nah but I respect your opinion. Again, this is looking at it right now. Depending on the remaining 4 events in the year will give me my best idea of who really deserves it. Like, say NaVi wins Epicenter and s1mple is MVP, sure it doesn't have Astralis, but it has Liquid at least. Also ECS is a no NaVi playing zone, so it will be interesting to see who would get the MVP if Astralis played. Then there are is Chicago and Blast as well as the Pro League Finals (which both Ast and NaVi are pretty much guaranteed at this point). These 3 in particular will decide for me who deserves it. If dev1ce really does outshine s1mple or at least his team wins 2 of the 3 tournaments with dev1ce being impressive, I will say dev1ce wins.
Just keep in mind, NaVi aren't the same team as Astralis, Edward and Zeus may be bots, but it doesn't take away too much from s1mple and electronic