that's you who post anecdotes. You are aware that empirical evidence is the way to go and not subjective "set up player", "eco hunter", "baiter" and shit like that. Also overwhelming majority of people at all levels of cs agree that he is the best player. The only people who disagree are couple of edge lords who creates these stupid threads where and all arguments are the same - "set up player", "eco hunter", "baiter" and you never see any empirical data nor there exist any to back the claims. Look at his stats at first kills, hs percentage, awp kills, etc. He is dominating in almost every stat you can find. As for the setup, who cares. Every team who have star player sets up plays for him. That's logical - there most chances he will get the kill because he is most skilled. Why that is not OK??? Everyone hunts for ecos. Everyone plays the same game, everyone does every same thing. ANd even if he is the biggest eco hunter at cs, also who cares. To be the one who kills most ecos, you also must have skills to do that - like figuring out where people might hide, taking on hunt before enemy takes the possitions, be clever enough to cover all the ground.
TLDR: S1mple is the best, your thread sucks, you have nothing to back up your claims