#51 You are making mistakes or lying because Aristotle was not an atheist as you mistakenly stated, he acknowledged God's revelation as the "Unmoved mover" a concept of the existence of a supreme principle of nature. Secondly, Aristotle creates in a universal absolute law, and not in mere subjective opnions. Even Aristostéles wrote a few things about theology, it follows that he was theist, not atheist as you have misleadingly stated; for it is impossible to obtain some moral principle from the atheistic worldview, but if you consider it possible, i am challenging you to explain where you obtain the moral standard of atheism-materialist-evolutionist and show me the basis of human dignity and worth, for which you must respect some person. So, you can not open your mouth to criticize anything morality at all until you first show where to find morality, worth, and human dignity in atheism.
when the Gentiles, which have not the law [ 10 commandments], do by nature the things contained in the law [ 10 commandments ], these, having not the law, are a law unto themselves: Which shew the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and their thoughts the mean while accusing or else excusing one another;) Romans2:14,15
The Stoics before Christ who did not know the law of Moses said that in the universe certain laws operate that man breaks for his own risk, and that these laws are of nature and that man must live according to it.
Plutarch, another Greek philosopher said: Who will govern the governor? It is the Law, the Queen of all mortals and immortals, which is written in reason within the soul and never leaves its soul deprived of moral direction
But, this does not exist in the atheistic worldview. Where do you get the universal law from atheism?
They all recognized the UNIVERSAL Law above humanity , above society, and this law which God has implanted in all of us is the basis upon which all men will be judged, and no one can justify himself on the day of his judgment.
Everyone has the moral law of God written in their conscience, including you, people who have never heard the gospel, most primitive tribes, all know that they should love and respect their neighbor, because God wrote in their hearts, lying and defaming is wrong, and when they do they violate their conscience and know that God is their judge. The most primitive tribes that had ever spoken of the philosophers cultivated some moral principle as: to take care of the old and the sick people, to protect the children, to consider betrayal and adultery wrong, to punish thieves; showing that it was not the philosophy that brought these standards to the world.
But your problem, my atheist friend, is that without God you have no basis to say why we should respect and love next and why they have any value and dignity. Atheism gives you no basis to criticize anyone, the only foundation that atheism gives is that you can live like an animal and there is nothing wrong with that.