You do have a good taste for movies, I aleady watched The Silence of Lambs and Donnie Darko, The Pursuit of Happyness, Se7en, No Country for Old man and The Dark Knight I was willing to watch. Actually, we have almost the same taste for movies!
I will put The Shawshank Redemption and The Prestige into my list, if these are on the same leve as the other you mentioned, it will be at minimum amazing.
Thank you! I was in need of some great movies!
And If I could recommend you a great movie, watch Zodiac, I found it in this thread, and it was indeed a great movie.