Its not even close tbh and the fact is that s1mple carries to a level that is capable of single handedly carrying games and even tournaments. Autimatic is a great player on a medicore team, simple is a godlike player on a decent team but is so godlike that it makes that team look elite at times.
Literally no evidence to suggest otherwise. They have nearly identical stats vs top 20 teams, fallen has played more maps, and has had deeper runs meaning hes faced more difficult opponents and yet Tim who is mainly playing group stages vs worse teams is tied with him. It's pretty basic.