Currently at 32 votes. Need atleast 18 more.
Overall, I feel the new de_cache to be preferrable. I'm not incredibly fond of the overgrown state of the visuals. Like having all the plants growing up through the concretes and such. The wooden interiors are also not at all desirable for me. But the structural and prop changes, like to A site, are great. The broken fences in a few spots aren't my favorite. But I think they can become better if the clipping brushes on them is smoothed or even removed entirely. Checkers is much better for me now than in the past. I quite like the visual in checkers. The stained glass at the tree outside B site doesn't work for me either.
So visually, this map isn't especially my thing. In some cases it is. I like the tile in mid as well, and the red ibeam in mid is great. The improvements to the green gates, the blue squeaky door, the forklift, and the APC at A site are all outstanding.
My vote is for the new de_cache.