That filter doesn't account for top 10-5 teams which tarik is playing much more. It includes any team that go to Big Events like MIBR, Grayhound, North etc. Tarik is playing the best teams in the world most of the time.
Auti does have a better rating against top 10 teams than Tarik this year. Against top 10 teams Tarik has a rating of 1.01 while Autimatic' rating is 1.05
And thats while Autimatic has been in a shit team, just imagine what he could do in an actually decent team like EG.