I agree with your list, but I still think there's a possibility that S1mple is 4th.
Rating against top5: 1.16 (75 games, 51% of his games)
Rating against below top5: 1.26 (49% of his games)
Rating against top5: 1.27 (20 games, 20% of his games)
Rating against below top5: 1.28 (80% of his games)
So, S1mple's ratings is inflated due to the lack of plays against top5.
Also, evps and mvps, both with Elige ahead.
MVPs: 3 x 1
EVPs: 9 x 5
Still, I think hltv is kinda valuing rating too much, so s1mple may be #3, but it won't be a surprise to see Elige as #3.