who cars?? you are dead mens))
I just did both and I am alive. so no
You can't suffocate yourself by just holding your breath, hence the answer is neither.
It's a trick question, you won't die by holding your breath regardless of how long you can do it. You will, at most, pass out.
What do I win?
You are not dead. You are not thinking but you still have cerebral activity, you can still feel and see everything.
You don't have to think to breathe. The body has kind of a failsafe,
You can turn of the failsafe with Fentanyl. Just ask the Russian government after the Moscow theater hostage situation.
but you died y having no oxygen.
suicide isnt cause of death, it's not like suicide killed people in 9/11 if they jumped out of window.
but people also can't stop thinking.
if we stopped thinking we wouldnt answer your question.
both are correct, prove me wrong
You can't not think when you're dying nt 0/8
You wrote: if u stop thinking and breathing
So that means that you have stopped it your self, and you uave commited suicide because you stopped doing 2 most important things human does... ez pz
You don't die in few minutes. Question is dumb af. Same is to ask: What if you baked a cake and put cream on it so does it mean that you won the berlin or stockholm marathon? Baguette brain on fire here.
is this happens because we are from bulgaria?
if i stop thinking, i dont know if im breathing. so i breath again and survive. ezclap
It depends, if you try holding it you wont die. If you find an external way to stop breathing and do it on your free will thats suicide, the cause being not having oxygen. Otherwise its just death by lack of oxygen
If you stop thinking, you end up creating threads like this
0/8 just farming attention
This is probably the most braindead question i've ever come across.
It's a stupid question as you can't die this way, but hypothetically. The way in which you die is suicide, the cause is the lack of oxygen.
my brain almost died after reading your stupid question
It's unconscious suicide, but you can't stop thinking and breathing at the same time, because if you stopped stopped breathing you would be thinking and remembering to hold your breath.
Easy answer, you cant die.
u cant cuz u'd pass out and unconciously start breathing again
you don't die cuz there is oxygen in your body supplying it to your brain parts so you can think.
Plus idk how is it possible to stop thinking and breathing at the same?
Also if you stopped breathing and the oxygen supply to brain stops, then it is a suicide.
"stop" as if stop doing some activity then think and breathe? Would mean you are still normally alive.
u so happy about this useless sh1t question. omg get a life
"what if u stop thinking and breathing for few mins" That is called being unconscious. So you couldn't have died or committed suicide because you're not legally dead. You could have maybe attempted suicide or had a near death accident, but in the end you didn't die. You are now either awake or in a coma.
Why do you keep feeding the troll? The answer is obviously something really retarded and any logical answer posted here is "wrong".
committing suicide does not imply the specific method, therefore oxygen deprivation is just the method you chose to commit suicide
it's impossible stop thinking and breath voluntarily for few mins.
So, you won't die
if I really need to piss and don't go to the toilet and hold it till I piss my pants after falling asleep - does this mean I pissed my pants willingly?
already died by something else obviously, the only reason you wouldn't be able to breath for minutes except you're an apnoe diver but this exception falls with the second assumption
If you stop thinking that wouldn't be a suicide cuz wouldn't be intentional, so die from lack of oxygen!
you can't stop thinking and you can't stop breathing for minutes. You won't die, however hard you try, as long as there's oxygen around you
As I see it and all the logical answers are wrong
I think we need to put ourselves in a the new stage of being stupid to answer this question with is so hard and it takes a lot of effort to get to that point
if u stop thinking, so its not suicide.
It highly depends on where you are when you do it, a person can only survive without breathing for around 3 minutes, so if you stop breathing and then you are pushed into the water or open space, you'd probably end up dying and it would probably be murder, but if you stop breathing and thinking for a few minutes and then fell in the water, it would be suicide if you fell in willingly, but not suicide and just an accident if you stopped thinking unwillingly.
what does thinking and breathing have to do with eachother?
If you stop thinking you cannot hold your breath
I doubt it's possible to die from few minutes of not breathing. If you're not under water, then there is no reason why body wouldn't just resume breathing. Moreover, the instinct would probably kick in when it becomes a problem for body functions. Lot of people have sleep apnea and they seem to survive through it just fine.
But if it did happen, then it'd be accident. And if you did that intentionally and died as result, then rather than suicide I'd look at it as some special case of darwin awards.
not dead after few mins without oxygen. Btw. humans cannot kill themselves with holding breath.
Just because I'm not thinking doesn't mean I'm not me. Its a suicide
If one "thinks outside the box" , one could come up with a million answers to that question. The person could be just sleeping, for example, and some health issue made him stop breathing for some time.
Congratulations to pRopaaNS for solving this question and ur in the 1% since one of the word in his comment is the answer to this question. looks like the others are hardstuck in 99% sadly
you cant die like that you will automatically breathe in you cant die by self suffocation
my superior brain thinks 24/7, if im not thinking then im dead.
shut up bitch dont tell me whats right and whats wrong, UR WRONG AND U DONT GET ANY CHANCES
if its hypothetical tho lets say "if you stop " means you chose to stop thinking and you chose to stop breathing so if you die its a suicide because even if you dont think during 2 mins you chose to stop breathing prior to those 2 mins hence its your own decision meaning its a suicide
ur in a coma - or between death and being alive. this means, you are schroedingers cat.
depends on the way you lose oxygen, if you voluntarily do it, suicide,
if you dont, just death
but what about the gold fish
As far a am I aware, it is impossible to die from you holding your breath, because after a while your body will force you to breathe. Anyways, once you go unconscious, you will start breathing anyways and be okay.
since right now im a bit lazy now to reply and said u have how many try left .. heres the winner and champion in the 1% after me answer and u need to find the word in this comment that is the absolute answer to this hard extreme question :
" I doubt it's possible to die from few minutes of not breathing. If you're not under water, then there is no reason why body wouldn't just resume breathing. Moreover, the instinct would probably kick in when it becomes a problem for body functions. Lot of people have sleep apnea and they seem to survive through it just fine.
But if it did happen, then it'd be accident. And if you did that intentionally and died as result, then rather than suicide I'd look at it as some special case of darwin awards. "
good luck . dont worry everyone have infinite chance now! i believe in all of u smart hltv people ! cya in few hours . dont hesitate to answer anything now
This is easily the by far most retarded thread by the most retarded OP I have EVER seen on hltv.
It's physically impossible for humans to just stop breathing, you would need some sort of tool to do so and this would make it suicide
nt you cant breathe or think on a flat earth, that means we are already dead
I have stopped thinking and breathing at the same time once in my life.
It was when I came out from my mother's vagina. It was so tight, I wasnt able to breath for new minutes.
you cant die my nigga, you gonna be well breathing again when you passed out
Breathing doesn't require thinking, so if you stop thinking you can't stop breathing. If you hold your breath you have to think about it, hence you're thinking. You can't do both simultaneously
u cant kill urself by not breathing
You didnt die
few mins is not deadly
Oxygen, because your not thinking to breathe
you died by suicide because you did not use oxygen. so its both.`
you actively chose to not breath and not use the oxygen. but oxygen didnt directly kill you because it was you who didnt breath that made you die. not the oxygen directly.
Actually you don't need to think to breath, you just need to have brain for that, so you'll be all good.
What is this stupid question?
You die cuz not because of "or" condition you die cuz of an "and" condition.
You make suicide and die by lack of oxygen.
You are able to recover, so technically you are in the same state as you die, atleast for the first seconds.
Your heart is beating, and your brain controlling all your muscles, microscopic movements etc.
Meaning you are mentally dead (1iquser) but not ACTUALLY dead. Its like being in a coma, but you can control it.
U can't die just for stoping to breathing
You cant die doing that cuz "bulbo"(idk in english) doesnt let u do that.
You at most can fall into coma.
u can't die from not breathing
Well you literally can't. First the co2 levels would rise to high that your cells would tell your brain to breath out and get rid of it. And even if you managed to hold your breath until you passed out you would automatically start breathing and regulating the co2 and 02 levels before you could actually die.
But for the question in mind if you stopped thinking you could not stop breathing as to do that would have to be an active thought else the brain would just take over and breath.
Gotta leave such a stupid question for a frenchman to ask :o
Dear Ladies and Gentleman,
Congratulations to qbZRD be 2nd hltv problem solver after pRopaaNS and me in 1% . looks like hltv still has many fail . its okay if u fail since its 99% fail . Alright times up and i will tell u all the answer. listen carefully, the answer to the question is Neither. Since its called sleeping. only sleeping nothing else. u can call it nap too but nap has no time for us to dream to trigger us in unconcious state aka stop thinking and breathing for few mins in our own soul and body but outside it other people can see how we still breathing but in face if u noticed.. everytime after u wake up u will wake up taking a deep breath instead of exhaling it . and ur body will start thinking and breathing back. yeah feel free to angry or mad becoz of failling since this is 99% everyone in world will fail and only 1% can answer. now after this everyone can be 1% . ur welcome and have a nice day ladies and gentleman ~!
Purposely, its suicide
Accidentally, lack of oxygen
You can’t die from holding you breath voluntarily
If u hold ur breath for long enough u pass out and start manualy breathing
you will pass out and start breathing without thinking about it. so it is impossible to die by holding your breath
Stupid question. You obviously don't die. I give you 2more tries to fix/rephrase your statement.
Neither cuz you won’t die lol
Your heart is beating then you alive!
There are 2 deaths physical and mental
we are body and soul.
ps: you will breathe automatically
You can't stop breathing if you stop thinking before try not to breath, like your brain does not understand to stop breathing.
How can you hold your breathe without thinking of holding your breathe. It's impossible
I can hold my breath for a few minutes, so I donut die
Theres still activity in your brain so you didn't dieded.
Question doesn't have correct answer since it is dependent on the environment you are in
for example, nothing will happen to you if you are in a coma and attached to machines, but you will die ez when you float through space without a suit
You can't died by stopping your breath because your body will forcefully makes you breathe
You cannot not think, it's impossible, and if you stop breathing, you pass out, so you'll breath again
But imagine that you can not think and stop breathing, you die from both
Just solved it, it's easy
You cant die in a Simulation.
Says for a few minutes, so you didnt die.
If a rooster laid and egg on a roof which side would it roll off of?
they die by torture of jonathan e
HAHAHAHHAHHAHAHH SO FUNNY LMFAO HAHAHAHAHHA
breathing is involuntary so if you stop thinking you will keep breathing
You can't stop breathing. So, no.
Death is the absence of brain function so it means you died before you stopped thinking and breathing, and it was due to unknown reasons. This is just in general how death works, and the lack of oxygen or suicide part is a trick that isn't relevant.
EDIT it seems ur saying its something relating to sleep is the answer but im still correct, as far as I know there isnt a sleep disorder that can stop you completely from thinking, because you still subconsciously think in your sleep and there will always be brain function. Please explain how it is possible to quit subconscious thinking and still be alive in your sleep. Seems to me I'm correct since you will always have some kind of brain function if you're alive so to truly stop thinking you must be dead.
if you die from jumping of a tall building does that mean u died by suicide or just misjudging the height of the building