That could very well be.
Time will tell.
It could also have to do with karrigans style of ingame leading as it starts to become a pattern considering his carrier.
Seeing he had the luxury of being with talent (TSM aka Astralis, FaZe and now Mousesports)
Where one could argue that any ingame leader they would listen too and buy into his system with some level of understand of the game would suffice.
for a certain time period.
aka Xist, MSL, Adren, golden etc
eventho that could be false as well and karrigan could just be an good ingame leader that just had this pattern happen to him twice by coincidence and I should not bind to this conclusion yet.
Saying he was just unlucky and lucky at the same time in his carreer.
Unless the same happens at mousesports this time around.
That shouldnt be the case now though since he doesnt have to deal with a solid core(dupree,xyp,device) that differ on viewing the game with him nor does he have to deal with the egos of previous legends (if that where a problem at all apart from Niko).
No he deals with youngsters now where karrigan is the legend himself as IGL and with I presume a flexible ChrisJ. because that is how we dutchies usually are... but mind you not always.
In conclusion it can go either way at this point and time will tell the story.
Personally I dont like karrigan.
and you could look at this way, so far the astralis core was right and luckily met glave.
if Faze recovers now then they could of been right as well. although guardians slump should also have been taken into account outside the faze honeymoon period.