It's all about the impact... now, it's fairly hard to generalize how impactful supports vs. carries are, that's why we need the eye test in addition to the stats to make an accurate assessment. I really dislike how many people on HLTV tend to say "player xyz is complete garbage" when they are the hard entry and not even given the opportunity to win aim duels. Same goes for "player zyx is the star player but he's baiting all the time" even though it is perfectly logical that the most individually skilled player on the team should have more than one opportunity at getting frags in each round. All in all, people just judge too quickly. Yes, some support players do not have the individual level to play in certain teams, some star players are set up too much and made look better than they actually are, but that certainly doesn't apply to everyone, yet people behave like there are only star & support players with nothing in between.