the example you used is completely irrelevant and is not logical at all. It would be correct if you said "The fact that people who don't drive cars comment on how bus and truck drivers should do it, is amazing." that's analogical to what I said
The fact that bus and truck drivers who don't even design and build cars in the factory get to drive, pick up passengers & cargo is not amazing at all.
I didn't say these "experts" should be professional players too, I only said that Thorin, for example doesn't even have a mge rank.
In chess, for example, people who cast top tier games, are usually grandmasters or international masters, at least, and it makes casting really interesting, and at least it makes sense.
I just hate the fact that a person who doesn't really understand anything within the game, doesn't really understand roles and real in-game reasons of faze's falure, he can't and doesn't analyze the rounds, he can't analyze, who really in this team doesn't do his job, which leads to round losses, he can only look at the surface. I'm so sure about that because I myself can do THE SAME conclusions that Thorin usually makes, and I am a noob at the game, and these people get to criticize people who are one of the best at what they're doing