You should not go for any Audi car. It's just a problematic car which will be repaired more than you use it. But you should go for a german car, it's the best if you want speed, acceleration and good looks. Not saying that cars from the US isn't, but you are more into power and not the other aspects as much. Sure BMW is a great car, especially the M2 and M5. But we use to call them "Bästis med verkstaden", which means "Best friend with the garage/workshop" or whatever. Not sure where in the US you live, but if you live in a colder climate, then that's nothing for you as they tend to rust easily. The best car you can get is an Mercedes. It's just raw! I would go for a Mercedes AMG. Maybe something like the Mercedes AMG C63. It's fast, got the looks, got the luxurity and everything is pure joy!
But if you would just choose from the 3 cars you listed yourself, I would have chosen the Dodge Charger Hellcat. It's my favourite muscle car. Haven't driven it myself but I will probably get one next summer! :)
BTW, if you want a SUV sometime. Get the Mercedes AMG GLC 63 with the biggest motor. That's so fun to ride! I've driven many SUV's but that one always gives me a smile on my face as soon as I jump in it. Had one last year, which I chipped! Best car I've had!