Top1 2020 - An Objective take, in my humble opinion
Looking objectively (in my humble opinion), Zywoo has a slight edge over s1mple, at THIS juncture.
Since the rating (Rating 2.0 already includes everything like impact, KAST, ADR, KDR, multi-kills, clutches, entries, and 12 more factors) is exactly the same, let's talk about achievements:
s1mple was in 5 finals, and won 2 (ICE Challenge 2020 - grand finalist, IEM Katowice 2020 -winner, ESL Pro League season 12 - finalist, IEM Beijing - finalist, Clutch Island - winner). If we want to count Blast Spring 2020 regular season and Blast Fall 2020 regular season, then 7 finals total and won/jointly won 3. But I am not counting those 2. In addition to this, he and his team are top3/top4 at Dreamhack Masters Spring 2020, top3/top4 at Blast Spring Finals 2020, top3/top4 at ESL Pro League season 11. And finally of course, the only actual official LAN MVP of 2020 is with s1mple, for the most important tournament.
Zywoo has been in 5 finals and won 1. Just like above, I am not counting Blast Fall 2020 Regular season, or the blast spring showdown 2020 where ENCE was jointly first. Only absolute winners are counted, just like for s1mple. If we counted these, then again 7 finals for Zywoo/Vitality and won/jointly won 3 tournaments. But, we don't count those. In addition, Vitality actually had a slow start to 2020, and picked up pace after May/June. There are no other top3/top4 finishes for Vitality, the way there are for Navi, simply because Vitality has been to almost every single grand final since then :D. And the ones where they didn't make it to grand finals, they were out long before top3/top4 (example: Knocked out in groups of EPL-12).
Thus, rating wise, both are exactly the same. In terms of number of tournaments - absolute victories/joint victories, they are exactly the same (7-3 for both).
Therefore, the difference between these 2 arises, because of a slightly more high-rated performance at more tournaments in 2020 by Zywoo, even if Vitality lost. That alone puts him at a slight edge over s1mple, at this point.
Hence, in their remaining 2 tournaments (BLAST Fall Finals 2020 and IEM Global Challenge 2020), if Zywoo wins one, he is at a significant advantage over s1mple for the Top1 spot. If Zywoo wins both, his top1 is undisputed and guaranteed. If s1mple wins both, he is at a significant advantage over Zywoo for the top1 spot. If s1mple wins one and closely loses the other, and Zywoo wins it, then they are literally equal. If both fail and don't do shit, Zywoo is already has an edge over s1mple (just like right now), and in that case Zywoo would take top1.
PS: I have tremendous respect both the "players". I hope that this leads to a civil discussion and not a keyboard war.