I will copy/past my review on metacritic about this game: When i started this game i was really expecting one of the best games of all time, because of all the praise this game gets. I am really disappointed.
The Story is ordinary, a world that has be taken by a fungus, and the citizens become zombies. Them we have a few that survived and now is fighting for their lives. We have so many game with similar story.
The characters has a good development, and this is the reason i give 4 to this game
The IA is so stupid that broke the immersion of the game. Seeing Elie walking in the front of a enemy and none of they reacting at all is ridiculous. If the game has stupid zombies it's fine, but people beeing so stupid as zombies really broke the game.
The Stealth is awful, as you throw a bottle near the enemy and has no reaction, but sometimes you throw and a guy from the otherside of the map comes to see what's happening, totally bad maded.
The combat is bad either, with really simplistic movements, and repetitive.
The game ending is what i was hoping to be the savior of the game, but unfortunately wasn't.
Seeing joel rushing to a hospital full of fireflies, and killing all of then like he was Rambo, is laughable. The worse is that he alone kill practically a army and saves Ellie in the end of it. The story would be so more impacting if Ellie died to save the world. They could have shown it a few years later, the world rising up after healing came, showing Joel rising emotionally in a healed world. They could even make a new game showing this, but not, unfortunately.