i played both, i just can to say that: in terms of how the game is made, that is, technically rdr 2 is better. But it's fck boring, and the characters there are also no interesting. One Johny from tw3 is more interesting than all characters and the main story in rdr2.
Also imo tw3 is the best game ever made, that game feels live, it's hard to describe but it's something it has and no one else game has.
After i finished tw3 i couldn't play any other games(not counting csgo).
Very close to its' level is dark souls 3.
Inb4 both games get called garbage by gatekeepers
Rdr2 can't even compete with Witcher 3.
There won't be another game as great as the witcher in years to come
witcher 3 is just bloated, nowhere near as good as 1 and 2
Both are better than The Last of Us 2.
red dead redemption is better
Both games very good but for me rdr2 is better.
Rdr is so slow and boring, Arthur is an old alcoolic with 70IQ
The story is slow and boring, the quest in the Witcher where you have to chose the new King of Skellige is better than the entire story of rdr
Sadie was the only good character imo
not even gonna mention all the genre and setting differences and the fact that its all subjective, imagine comparing 2015 and 2018 games
RDR2 is the greatest game of all time