you're right, irrelevant was wrong word. your first reply was just a dogshit argument
as for contradictory, you first claim that he's just lucky. i then go on to say that it's because he has security and stays isolated, which you then confirm with your second comment. it could either be contradictory or you changing your argument in the second reply.
it's probably latter since your first point was dogshit, so lets agree that we both rekted ourselves