Shakezullah is inexperienced but I don't see why tarik is a better IGL than him? Tarik won the major but he didn't even stay IGL afterwards for very long if I recall correctly. If the US has a super team you'd need to find a good IGL in the lower tier and give them a shot IMO, tarik just isn't good enough in my mind to lead such a team. I'd compare it to Gambit, they found nafany and he turned out to be good IGL, who's to say there's not a good IGL in our lower scene too?
Aside from that I agree with the team, hard to pick between oSee and junior though