I pretty much had that Cobble 1vs4 by Snax in mind when I was typing the previous post. The call had everything, the memorable phrase with the Big Apple (although "Oh Guardian, bye-bye" deserves a shout too), the flow, the hype... and also the crowd getting into it. That helps a lot too. Hell, even that small "Oh no" from Henry added to it.
Obviously I'm biased as all hell here (I miss the days of top tier Polish CS), but this is probably my favorite call all-time. Not necessarily saying it's the best one of all time (there's at least 4-5 calls that all have a similar level, this one included), but it just makes me smile.