Well if you think stats are showing who is better you are obviously just braindead. Forest is a star player in NiP, there is no deny. Him and GTR are carrying this team so... yea it is pretty clear he has to perform and make frags. You have to be really stupid to not realise that. On the other hand NEO is playing a support role in VP, he is making openings for other players (Snax, byali, pasha) to shine.
You can't really tell who is better if they are playing on different positions. Yet when they were playing on pretty much same spots (back in 1.6) in the team, Neo was godlike.