Regarding the Witcher 3, Mafia 1, Mass Effect 1-3 overrated games meme:
It has been forcibly turned into a meme by the fans of those games. It was done on purpose to suppress criticism of those games by making those who say that the games are overrated look absurd because they are just spreading a meme now. The meme shouldn't even exist because it's not a joke, it's the truth. Those games are _severely_ overrated.
Skyrim > Cyberpunk > Witcher 3